subhead image

About Defeasance

Defeasance Case Studies

Borrowers using defeasance are getting the most out of their real estate. See the cases below to understand how defeasance can help your bottom line.

 
iconsPrintable Page

CASE 1: INVESTOR DEFEASES TO A HIGHER SALES PRICE

Multi-family property sold with defeasance generates additional $1.2m for seller

Situation: A multi-family investor put a mature 75-unit apartment building on the market in 2006 to unlock equity for reinvestment. The investor purchased the building in 2001 for $10m, financed with an $8m conduit loan at 8% interest.

Initial Marketing: The investor initially offered the property with assumption of the $7.6m outstanding loan balance, and five year remaining term. At the $16m asking price (cap rate of 6.5%), buyers were required to put up $8.4m cash. Due to the high equity requirement, only two buyers made offers, the highest for only $15m. The seller received feedback that the loan assumption made the deal unattractive.

Property Re-offered: The investor turned to defeasance to see if more competitive buyers could be engaged if the property were sold unencumbered. The re-offered property, lien removed through a defeasance, was sold for $17.2m after receiving bids from seven potential buyers.

Results: Even after the $990k defeasance costs of (including the defeasance premium and all fees), the investor netted $8.6m, $1.2m more than he would have made without the defeasance.

CASE 2: DEFEASANCE ENABLES FAVORABLE REFINANCE

Retail center recapitalized with defeasance, unlocking $6.2m of equity

Situation: An aging retail center purchased for $15.5m in 1999 with a 10 year, 7.5% conduit loan at 70% LTV needed a facelift and new roof in 2006. Although reserves could not cover the expense, a $22.5m appraisal confirmed substantial equity in the property.

Property Refinanced: The original conduit loan had three years remaining, with a principal balance of $10m. This loan was defeased concurrently with new 10 year CMBS financing secured at 6% interest and 80% LTV.

Results: After total defeasance costs of $800k , the owners were able to access $6.2m in hard-earned equity otherwise unavailable without the defeasance, and obtained substantial interest savings on the new loan as well.